Yes Virginia, there is a state Pet Trust
Does Virginia have pet a trust law? I am concerned about my little dog, Alice, who is an Affenpinscher.
Maybelle, Manassas, Virginia
Yes, Virginia…sorry I could not resist…yes, Maybelle, Virginia does have a Pet Trust Statute. However, I have to admit that I knew that, but I had no idea what an Affenpinscher was until I looked it up.
The Animal Welfare League of Arlington Virginia reported that in 2006,
“Virginia proudly joined 37 other states with a pet trust statute. This means that Virginia is also a little late to the game, but at least now Virginians can rest assured that their furry friends will be taken care of in case something ever happens to the pet's guardian. Pet owners may now designate a caretaker for their pet(s) and a trustee who ensures that the money is spent on the pet. Previously, if a pet's guardian passed away and left money in their will to take care of the pet, anyone could contest the provision and the pet could find himself in the shelter -- no cash, no home, no guardian. This statute puts an end to this injustice."
In its 2005 Session, the Virginia General Assembly enacted Senate Bill 891, the Uniform Trust Code (“UTC”), with modifications.
It provides that a trust may be created to provide for the care of an animal alive during the settlor's lifetime. The trust terminates upon the death of the animal or, if the trust was created to provide for the care of more than one animal alive during the settlor's lifetime, upon the death of the last surviving animal.
The instrument creating the trust shall be liberally construed to bring the transfer within the scope of trusts governed by this section, to presume against the merely precatory or honorary nature of the disposition, and to carry out the general intent of the transferor.
A trust authorized by this section may be enforced by a person appointed in the terms of the trust or, if no person is so appointed, by a person appointed by the court.
Except as ordered by a court or required by the trust instrument, no filing, report, registration, periodic accounting, separate maintenance of funds, appointment, or surety bond shall be required by reason of the existence of the fiduciary relationship of the trustee.
Property of a trust authorized by this section may be applied only to its intended use, except to the extent the court determines that the value of the trust property exceeds the amount required for the intended use.
Except as otherwise provided in the terms of the trust, property not required for the intended use shall be distributed to the settlor, if then living. If the settlor is deceased, such property shall be distributed pursuant to the residuary clause of the settlor's will if the trust for the animal was created in a preresiduary clause in the will or pursuant to the residuary provisions of the inter vivos trust if the trust for the animal was created in a preresiduary clause in the trust instrument; otherwise, such property shall be distributed to the settlor's successors in interest.
Those of you that are regular readers of this Blog will certainly note that the Virginia Pet Statute outline is very similar if not identical to other state Pet Statutes.
Alabama Code Protection for Pets Trusts
On January 1, 2007, Alabama became the 16th state to adopt the Uniform Trust Code. In doing so, the “Yellowhammer State”* adopted the Trust language of the Uniform Trust Code to allow for a Trust for the Care of an Animal.
The Comment to the Code states that the purpose is to validate so called honorary trusts. Unlike honorary trusts created pursuant to the common law of trusts, which are arguably no more than powers of appointment, the trusts created by this and the next section are valid and enforceable.
Additionally, the Code provides that a trust for the care of an animal may last for the life of the animal. While the animal will ordinarily be alive on the date the trust is created, an animal may be added as a beneficiary after that date as long as the addition is made prior to the Settlor’s death. Animals in gestation but not yet born at the time of the trust’s creation may also be covered by its terms. A trust authorized by this section may be created to benefit one designated animal or several designated animals.
We have recently discussed, here and here, the close relationship in the ongoing ever changing legal theories for treatments of pets as mere chattel or more akin to a family member.
It is interesting to note that additional Comments to the Alabama Code state in part…
Non-charitable trusts ordinarily may be enforced by their beneficiaries. Charitable trusts may be enforced by the state’s attorney general or by a person deemed to have a special interest. But at common law, a trust for the care of an animal or a trust without an ascertainable beneficiary created for a non-charitable purpose was unenforceable because there was no person authorized to enforce the trustee’s obligations…The intended use of a trust authorized by either section may be enforced by a person designated in the terms of the trust or, if none, by a person appointed by the court. ..If the trust is created for the care of an animal, then a person with an interest in the welfare of the animal has standing to petition for an appointment. The person appointed by the court to enforce the trust should also be a person who has exhibited an interest in the animal’s welfare. The concept of granting standing to a person with a demonstrated interest in the animal’s welfare is derived from the Uniform Guardianship and Protective Proceedings Act, which allows a person interested in the welfare of a ward or protected person to file petitions on behalf of the ward or protected person. See, e.g., UNIFORM PROBATE CODE §§ 5-210(b), 5-414(a)… (our emphasis)
We generally think of humans as seeking protection under a Guardianship or Protective Order proceeding.
In the Code the protection afforded a ward or protected person is also granted to an animal!
(Alabama has been known as the “Yellowhammer State” since the Civil War. The yellowhammer nickname was applied to the Confederate soldiers from Alabama when a company of young cavalry soldiers from Huntsville, under the command of Rev. D.C. Kelly, arrived at Hopkinsville, KY, where Gen. Forrest's troops were stationed. The officers and men of the Huntsville Company wore fine, new uniforms, whereas the soldiers who had long been on the battlefields were dressed in faded, worn uniforms. On the sleeves, collars and coattails of the new cavalry troop were bits of brilliant yellow cloth. As the company rode past Company A, Will Arnett cried out in greeting "Yellowhammer, Yellowhammer, flicker, flicker!" The greeting brought a roar of laughter from the men and from that moment the Huntsville soldiers were spoken of as the "yellowhammer company." The term quickly spread throughout the Confederate Army and all Alabama troops were referred to unofficially as the "Yellowhammers.")
Holding the Pet Trustee Accountable
We recently, visited the responsibilities of the Pet Trustee, see here and determined that their duties mirror those of other Trustees.
In addition to the restrictions imposed in the Trust Agreement , we noted that the Uniform Trust Code also sets out specific expectations for the Trustee.
What happens if the Trustee fails to adhere to the restrictions and steps outside the parameters of the power structure?
If a Trustee is believed to have breached their duties under the Trust Agreement or threatens to do so, what ability does the Court have to control the actions of the Trustee?
Under the common law there were limited remedies available for a breach of duty action again the Trustee. Only the Beneficiary and any Co-Trustee could bring the action and it was a matter for the Court to review.
The legislatures have now provided in most states, that others may represent a Beneficiary if legal action against the Trustee becomes necessary.
In the case of a Pet Trust, the Pet Caretaker would be able to bring an action of the behalf of the Pet.
Generally the Court can order the Trustee to do any number of things, including ordering the Trustee to perform the Trustee’s duties as set out in the Trust or to stop the Trustee from committing a breach of that agreement; order the Trustee to repay money or restore property to the Trust and order the trustee to account for all assets.
In some circumstances the Court can suspend the activities of the Trustee or even remove them from their duties or deny them any compensation for their work.
Many states have also written specific remedies that are available if a Trustee is in violation of their duties. Usually, these remedies are contained within the State's Trust Code and are identical or closely similar to those of the Uniform Trust Code.
Responsibilities of a Pet Trustee
The Uniform Trust Code, adopted by a majority of the states since its initial draft inception in 2000, has been the underlying strength of the new growth phase of Pet Trusts.
We have previously minimally defined the role of the Trustee.
Generally speaking, the duties and responsibilities of a Trustee for a Pet Trust are no more or less than any other Trustee.
The Trust Agreement itself will set out the specific role of the Trustee and set the parameters of the powers of the Trustee.
The Uniform Trust Code also defines in detail, the duties and powers of the Trustee that have been accumulated as established by the courts and the legislatures throughout the years.
Beginning with Section 801, DUTY TO ADMINISTER TRUST, which states…
Upon acceptance of a trusteeship, the trustee shall administer the trust in good faith, in accordance with its terms and purposes and the interests of the beneficiaries, and in accordance with this [Code].
The Code sets out in great detail the expectations of the Trustee, including definitions and explanations of the needed loyalty and impartiality of the Trustee as well as the accumulation, control and accounting of the Trust property.
Your choice of a Trustee for your Pet Trust, whether an organization or an individual should not be taken lightly. Although their responsibilities are set high and can be closely monitored by your Pet Caretaker, you will be out of the picture and the decisions will be made by someone else
You will no longer have control of the property that you have set aside for the care and protection of your pet.
Chose your Pet Trustee wisely.
